2022-06-30 Human Experience WG Meeting

Time

Item

Lead

Notes

5 mins

• Welcome & antitrust notice

• Agenda review

Kalin

• Antitrust Policy Notice: Attendees are reminded to adhere to the meeting agenda and not participate in activities prohibited under antitrust and competition laws. Only members of ToIP who have signed the necessary agreements are permitted to participate in this activity beyond an observer role.

• Join ToIP if not already a member

  • Consent to meeting recording?

10 mins

Intro's & Updates

Kalin

SSI Harms Whitepaper TF Update (Nicky)  TF Wiki page link

• White paper now outlined and main body of writing will happen in next month

• Use of Rumsfeld approach to structure 

  • Phil: perhaps call it the Johari window? (Fewer war crime associations.)

• Now defining key #harms-tf terms and mental model for like agency, power, human harm, resilience, livelihood assets and vulnerability see our Miroboard here

• Direct feedback based on interviews with indigenous people for grassroots input (edge case)

• As usual all contributions warmly welcome 

@Vikas Malhotra queried purpose of Harms TF and highlighted issue about over vs under-identification

@Phil Wolff commented: 

harms from identity vs. decentralized identity
can we reference harms arising from the SSI principles (http://www.lifewithalacrity.com/2016/04/the-path-to-self-soverereign-identity.html) and ToIP design principles (https://trustoverip.org/blog/2022/01/24/the-trust-over-ip-foundation-publishes-new-introduction-and-design-principles/)

5 mins

EFWG x-pollination

Andrew

Presentation Ecosystem Components

Document Ecosystem Components

Anyone in the group willing to support this work of the EFWG also possibility of sharing a session with them that

@Phil Wolff commented: It's not clear to me that there are mechanisms for "ecosystem cohesion". feedback loops (and corrective systems) that keep an ecosystem stable. e.g. detecting a DDOS attack on a registry and responding well. or detecting a human harm. or cryptographic assumptions are no longer true (see quantum computing).
@Andrew Slack important to use opportunity to understand the interactions and relationships that occur across the domain and eco-system.  So work some x-pollination with the group to define how the other two work together

5 mins

HXWG Terms Wiki

Nicky

We now have our HXWG Terms wiki 

This is the CTWG process - there is a toolbox building around it.

@Nicky Hickman is a guinea-pig at the CTWG and so familiar with process etc.  I am one of the curators but need at least one other to work with me.  Any volunteers!?

@Andrew Slack agreed to act as co-curator

What are the key concepts and terms we want to work on? (e.g. human experience, autonomy, bodily autonomy, socio-technical system), 

What are the ingestion methods we want to use?  e.g. g-docs or confluence wiki?

15 mins

Implementers

Kalin

After the summer we will run a series of interviews with SSI implementers.

Here is our wiki page for adding questions 

Potential x-over with EFWG work on implementers, they have already had Trinsic for example

15 mins

Deliverables

Andrew

Scenarios - nearly complete, where should it be stored? how does it iteratively grow and develop, get feedback etc?

@Nicky Hickman voted for confluence wiki

@Phil Wolff asked who it is for.

@Nicky Hickman suggested a panel discussion to introduce the deliverable with a short video as a complement

Expert series reflections

What have we learnt, how this has helped us in definition & scoping of HXWG - try to deliver over the summer - any contributors very welcome.

@Phil Wolff is working on "Consent Doesn't Scale"  for mid July 

10 mins

Close & Actions

Kalin

@Andrew Slack to round off the scenarios deliverable and add to wiki

@Nicky Hickman to add Andrew as a curator in HXWG

Stay in touch with EFWG