2023-09-20 CEPTF Meeting Notes

Owned by mathieu
Last updated: Sept 20, 2023
3 min read

Meeting Date & Time

  •   This Task Force meets every Wednesdays at 09:00-10:00 ET / 15:00-16:00 CET (see the Calendar of ToIP Meetings for full meeting logistics including Zoom links)

Zoom Meeting Recording

Attendees

NA/EU Meeting

No APAC meeting.

Agenda Items and Notes (including all relevant links)

TimeAgenda ItemLeadNotes
5 min
  • Start recording
  • Welcome & antitrust notice
  • Introduction of new members
  • Agenda review
Chairs
  • Antitrust Policy Notice: Attendees are reminded to adhere to the meeting agenda and not participate in activities prohibited under antitrust and competition laws. Only members of ToIP who have signed the necessary agreements are permitted to participate in this activity beyond an observer role.
  • New Members:
    • Mirko Mollik - doing work in OWF on credential profiles and more, interested in possible collaboration
    • Stephen Mugisha
55 minsGeneral agenda updates from issuance protocol progress
  • Update from contributors on ongoing 4 issuance documents
  • Experience of filling it out (ISO and OpenID)
    • ISO 23330-3 (feedback from Subhasis)
      • Lots of items still in draft
      • Lots of references between -3 and -1
      • Looking for peer review to ensure proper documentation
      • Too many options in the ISO specs, struggled to document a bit due to multiple options
    • Sankarshan: noticed opportunity to link back documents to ToIP Glossary to ensure alignment
    • Drummond: Shared the ToIP Glossary Workspace
      • Important to also ensure alignment between various communities (e.g., OWF)
      • Let group know that the 'terminology engine', in collaboration with TNO will be ready this fall
    • Vlad: reviewed Hakan's comments and felt that some information didn't have a proper criteria to place it
    • Subhasis: feels that having peer reviews (architect of technical PO) is the only way to improve documentation and ensure we're providing value to end consumers of docs
  • Review Sankarshan's document: 
    • Suggestion to place the protocols in columns, and criteria in rows for better comparison
  • Hakan: worked on OpenID4VCI Document, will have it reviewed by Torsten and/or other protocol experts to review
  • Subhasis: reach out to Andrew Hughes to ask for peer review
  • Statuses of v1 issuance protocols documents
    • OIDC4VCI: 70%
    • ISO 23220-3: 90% 
    • ACDC: 70%
    • Issue Cred v2: 90%
  • Discuss idea of peer reviewing of each other's documents
  • Update on ToIP Blog post & IIW (Oct 10-12)

Decisions

Action Items

  • ACTION: Hakan Yildiz and Vladimir Simjanoski to take a stab at filling out the OpenID4VCI Document (here)
  • ACTION: Subhasis to take a stab at filling out the ISO 23220-3 Document (here)
  • ACTION: sankarshan to take a stab at create a table view
  • ACTION: sankarshan to update table view
  • ACTION: @Subhasis to complete ISO 23330-3 v1 document
  • ACTION: Vladimir Simjanoski and Hakan Yildiz to complete OpenID4VCI v1 document
  • ACTION: Hakan Yildiz to engage Accenture architecture team for feedback on utility of document
  • ACTION: Hakan Yildiz to talk with Torsten and see if we can connect with ARF decision makers to get their feedback/thoughts - wait for review to happen prior to this.
  • ACTION: mathieu Get general feedback from Stephen Curran and Kevin Griffin on the documents they filled
  • ACTION: mathieu to reach out to Anil John to get his feedback/thoughts
  • ACTION: mathieu to also reach out for ARF contacts from Viky to get feedback


Notes

From CEPTF Meeting:

From TAS Efforts - early draft: